Energy Service Bulletin, February 2004

New California building standards raise bar for efficiency measures

Updated building standards will require all new commercial buildings with low-slope roofs to be fitted with highly reflective "cool roofs." A study by the Florida Energy Center found that buildings with light colored, more reflective roofs use up to 40 percent less energy for cooling than darker roofs. (artwork courtesy of California Energy Commission)

The California Energy Commission recently voted unanimously to update Title 24, Part 6, the state's Energy Efficiency Standards for Residential and Nonresidential Buildings, incorporating new measures and technology to reduce energy use, including peak use.

The latest round of revisions are projected to cut the state's peak energy use by more than 180 MW annually after they go into effect in 2005. Utilities, window manufacturers, the California Building Industry Association and the Natural Resources Defense Council were among those applauding the approved changes.

"For utilities like the Sacramento Municipal Utility District that produce part of their power and buy the rest, the changes mean we will have to buy less power in the future," commented Jim Parks, SMUD program manager for energy efficiency and customer research and development.

Revisions target peak use
To develop the new standards, the energy commission conducted a public process, soliciting ideas, proposals and comments from all interested people. Staff contacted representatives from affected industries and citizens who signed up with the commission to receive notification. A consulting firm and a number of nationally recognized lighting experts also helped with the project.

The most significant changes focused on reducing peak energy use. Air conditioning loads on hot summer days can cause the state's need for power to nearly double. The new code requires residential buildings to install cool roofs — highly reflective, insulated roofing. In California, nine out of 10 rooftops reach summer peak temperatures of 150 degrees to 190 degrees. A cool roof can reduce those temperatures by as much as 50 degrees. That large temperature difference translates to a 20-percent reduction in air conditioning costs.

Ductwork, particularly in residential buildings, also received attention. Standards for new heating, ventilation and air conditioning equipment will require ductwork to be inspected and sealed to correct the inevitable large leaks in existing ducts. Also, several changes make space heating, cooling and ventilation systems more efficient in both residential and nonresidential buildings.

Standards address both indoor and outdoor lighting
Major improvements in efficient lighting technology made their way into the standards, too. The revisions require "big box" nonresidential buildings to be equipped with skylights and sensor controls to turn off electric lighting when natural daylight is sufficient. Also, all permanent fixtures must use state-of-the-art fluorescent lighting. Parks noted that the commission incorporated a recommendation by SMUD and a lighting manufacturer that the requirement for electronic fluorescent lighting ballasts be lowered from 18 watts to 13 watts, thus saving energy and improving performance.

Outdoor lighting and indoor and outdoor signage—areas building standards rarely cover—feature prominently in the new standards. Requirements for control, efficacy and maximum power densities for indoor lighting have been on California's books for more than 20 years. Acting on the directive of Senate Bill 5X, the energy commission extended those requirements to encompass outdoor lighting applications.

Training and resource materials bring building industry up to speed
The commission will work closely with building officials, builders and utilities to provide training on the new standards, educating everyone to the changes before they go into effect. CEC sponsors training centers at SMUD, Pacific Gas and Electric Company, Southern California Gas Company, San Diego Gas Company and Southern California Edison. The centers offer hands-on training for building officials and builders on construction techniques for complying with the standards. Each training center is equipped with displays of energy-efficient equipment and techniques, and labs and mock-up facilities for demonstrating diagnostic equipment.

Ongoing workshops and seminars reach a wide audience. "The building industry has to be apprised of changes in the standards," said Parks, "and utilities need to know how the standards are going to affect their energy efficiency programs. For example, rebate plans have to be adjusted to meet the changes."

Manuals play a big part in the education process as well. Legislation specifies that training materials must be updated no later than 180 days after the adoption of new standards. The CEC also produces design suggestions for meeting or exceeding the standards and a computer program for calculating energy consumption in residential and nonresidential buildings.

Building officials, energy consultants, builders, contractors and homeowners can get answers about specific applications of the standards from CEC's Energy Hotline. The toll-free service puts callers in direct contact with code specialists on the commission staff. Hotline staff also answer queries by e-mail.

Professionals and consumers outside the state can benefit from the CEC's expertise through the on-line Consumer Energy Center. The Web site offers consumer tips, videos, case studies, useful links and a glossary of energy terms. Visitors can download commission reports and manuals free of charge. While most documents pertain specifically to California, builders and utilities everywhere must deal with the same issues of environmental protection and wise energy use, and may gain valuable insight from California's experience.

Ongoing commitment to energy efficiency rewards Californians
The CEC adopted the first Energy Efficiency Standards for Residential and Nonresidential Buildings in 1978 to control electricity use that had been growing at an annual rate of 8 percent. The standards apply to new construction, including requirements for entire new buildings, additions and alterations and repairs to nonresidential buildings.

Periodic updates allow for the incorporation of new energy-efficient technologies and conservation methods. The 2000 energy crisis prompted an emergency update of the code with substantial changes aimed at reducing summer peak demand. Immediately after completing those revisions, the commission began the public process to consider more extensive requirements that could not be developed within the 120-day timeframe of the emergency proceeding. These changes make up the 2005 Standards the commission adopted on Nov. 5, 2003.

Title 24 sets an example for progressive energy conservation policy and drives California utilities to develop new strategies to save energy. "When the standards tighten, last year's energy savings become this year's norm, and we have to identify new measures to increase the savings," explained Parks.

The CEC estimates that from its inception to 2003, the code, along with standards for energy efficient appliances, saved Californians $56 billion in electricity and natural gas costs. In addition, it improved outdoor air quality by reducing emissions from powerplants and from natural gas combustion in furnaces, boilers and water heaters.

A recent study by the RAND Corporation found that energy efficiency has helped the state economy, too. California's Standards and other investments in energy efficiency have resulted in the state having very low energy intensity (energy consumption per economic output) compared to the rest of the United States. This led to a 3-percent increase in the state's economic growth, the equivalent of putting between $875 to $1,300 in the pocket of every Californian, creating jobs and increasing California's business competitiveness.